Luxe: Chanel Rouge Hydrabase in Fire, $28.50
Less: Styli-Style Hipstick in Happy, $8.49
"A fun, slightly iridescent red that can pass for the Chanel version. It even has the little bit of gold fleck in it. The one by Styli-Style is less emollient, but you'll get a lot of bang for your buck," says Stiles.
Luxe: Givenchy Rouge Interdit in Only Beige, $26.50
Less: Napoleon Perdis NP Set Lipstick in Washington, $15
"I am always on the quest for the perfect beige lipstick," says Stiles. "This one by Napoleon Perdis is a great color and a perfect texture. The glossiness and warmth of the color prevents you from looking too washed out, which matte beiges can do."
Luxe: Benefit Benetint Lip Balm, $20
Less: Flirt! Tint-a-Licious Lip Sheer in Lover, $10
"Benetint is such a great color and I love that it's sheer and just a little glossy," says Stiles. "This sheer bright pink from Flirt! is a really close match to the Benefit. Sheer brights are so modern and a great way to wear color."
Luxe: Giorgio Armani Sheer Lipstick in Plum, $25
Less: CoverGirl TruShine Lip Color in Plum Shine, $5.66
"I love Armani lip colors. All consistencies. I find their sheer and cream [formulas] are very similar to the formula of CoverGirl's TruShine Lip color," says Stern.
Luxe: Clinique Almost Lipstick in Black Honey, $14
Less: Neutrogena MoistureShine Soothing Lip Sheers in Ruby Bliss, $8.99
"Black Honey by Clinique has been on the best seller list years," says Stiles. "Ruby Bliss by Neutrogena is a great, affordable version. The sheer color makes you look polished, but doesn't feel too lipstick-y."
Luxe: Yves Saint Laurent Gloss Pur in Pure Coral, $29
Less: CoverGirl Amazemint Lip Gloss in Freedom of Peach, $5.79
"I am a huge fan of YSL's Gloss Pur, however [also like] the similar finish of CoverGirl's Amazemint Lip Gloss," Stern says.
Luxe: Cle de Peau Lip Gloss in No. 11, $47
Less: L'Oreal Paris Bare Naturale Gentle Lip Conditioner in Soft Bloom, $8.96
"This is such a sophisticated color for a drugstore lip gloss. It has a little iridescence but isn't super sparkly," Stiles says. "It's a beautiful sheer color that doesn't taste like candy! A huge bonus."
Luxe: Lipstick Queen Sinner Pink, $18
Less: CoverGirl Incredifull Lipcolor in Warm & Rosy, $6.99
Stiles found these two to be near-perfect matches. T
Luxe: Nars Lipstick in Kiss, $24
Less: Boots No7 Stay Perfect Lipstick in Velvet Kiss, $9.99
Both lipsticks have a burnt copper shade and the Boots No7 has the advantage of being long-lasting. TotalBeauty.com member 51lincoln says, "I am typically not a fan of long wear but when I need something that lasts 4+ hours I wear this."
Luxe: Lancome Juicy Tubes Sparkling Night in Sky Diamond, $18
Less: Mark Juice Gems in Juicy Cherry Pop, $6
The packaging of these two glosses is practically identical, so it makes sense that the texture and color are similar too. The difference? The Mark gloss looks red in the tube but goes on like a deeper, sheer pink. The Lancome gloss goes on sheer as well, but the shade is true to the way it looks in the tube.